The Rodman rule has been revised, but the fight to keep stars goes on

The Rodman rule has been revised, but the NWSL’s effort to keep its stars continues. The league settled a grievance with the players’ association, which argued that the original criteria violated federal labour law. The announcement was made on Friday.

The change removes the eight criteria used to designate a “High Impact Player”. Clubs can now spend that money on whichever player they choose. From next season, every NWSL player will be eligible under the rule, as will every player on the Spirit. Trinity Rodman, whose name inspired the policy, was among those who met the original criteria.

The NWSL has yet to reproduce the Morgan effect, associated with record crowds and adoring away fans. But the idea of rewarding players whose international profile brings additional appeal was built into the original criteria. For the Spirit, the revised rule raises the possibility of keeping a team capable of competing with Europe’s big spenders.

The league also needs to develop its media rights, market its leading names to broadcasters and establish itself as a top destination ahead of a World Cup. Its performances in international competitions, including the upcoming Club World Cup, are also part of the challenge.

The revision comes as the Spirit stands out in attendance figures. The club has an accessible stadium in a major city, a proud fanbase and a roster featuring several players who met the policy’s initial criteria, including Rodman. The original framework had eight categories: in 2025, three NWSL players — Rodman, Sophia Wilson and Marta — featured among SportsPro Media’s 150 most marketable athletes.

The change also raises a question about sporting stature: could an NWSL player win the Ballon d’Or after lifting the league trophy, helping secure a victory in January’s inaugural Club World Cup and then performing well at a World Cup? The rule has changed; persuading the best players to stay remains the challenge.